A little girl with a big passion for food.

Nutella-Stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt

Holy, motherload. My life has changed. Because of a cookie. This cookie.

The Bite-Sized Baker // Nutella-Stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt

It was gloomy, I was beyond lazy, and I had one thing on my mind… I wanted to bake something. I really shouldn’t restrict myself from baking… I just go crazy.

The Bite-Sized Baker // Nutella-Stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt

I had seen this recipe published on Tastespotting earlier in the week and I bookmarked it because I knew I couldn’t live another week without baking it. Not an exaggeration.  In my humble opinion, bookmarking is a pretty big deal now that I have Pinterest to pin the thousands of recipes I’m “going to try.” If I bookmark something, there is no possible way I will forget about it… Not like you could pay me to forget about cookies with browned butter, but you get the idea.

The Bite-Sized Baker // Nutella-Stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt

This recipe literally sang to me. Browned butter has never let me down, but for some reason I’ve never really tried sprinkling my cookies with sea salt. I have no idea why I’ve waited this long because the salty-sweet combination rocked my world. And then there was Nutella… I’m not one of those people who goes ga-ga over Nutella, but when it’s stuffed inside of a cookie I kind of lose my cool.

The Bite-Sized Baker // Nutella-Stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt

Ughh, they were so good that while writing this short post I ran into the kitchen to bake the remaining cookie dough and as soon as I am finished writing this post/devouring cookies I plan on baking a second batch… Why yes, I do have self-control.

The Bite-Sized Baker // Nutella-Stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt

Nutella-Stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt

Yield: 18 servings

Prep Time: 2 hours 15 minutes

Cook Time: 11 minutes

Ingredients:

  • 2 ¼ cup all-purpose flour
  • 1 ¼ teaspoons baking soda
  • ¼ teaspoon of salt
  • 2 sticks (1 cup) unsalted butter
  • 1 ¼ cup packed dark brown sugar
  • ¼ cup granulated sugar
  • 1 large egg plus 1 egg yolk
  • 1 ½ teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1 tablespoon plain greek yogurt
  • ½ cup semisweet chocolate chips
  • ½  cup milk chocolate chips
  • 1 jar of Nutella, chilled in refrigerator
  • Coarse sea salt for sprinkling
   

Directions:

  1. In a large bowl mix flour, baking soda, and salt until combined. In a saucepan over medium heat, melt and cook down the butter until little brown bits appear in the pan and you smell a nutty aroma. Remove from the heat.
  2. In the bowl of a stand mixer with the paddle attachment, mix together butter and sugars until fully incorporated. Beat in egg, yolk, vanilla, and yogurt until combined. Gradually add the dry ingredients until combined. Fold in chocolate chips.
  3. Place cookie dough in the refrigerator for 2 hours to let the flavors meld together.
  4. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Roll 1½ tablespoons of dough and flatten the dough to make a flat circle. Place 1 teaspoon of chilled Nutella in the middle then place another flat circle of cookie dough on top. Crimp edges to seal.
  5. Place dough balls on cookie sheet, 2 inches apart and bake 9-11 minutes or until the edges turn golden brown.
  6. Sprinkle with sea salt and let cool on wire racks.
recipe from Ambitious Kitchen.

163 comments on “Nutella-Stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt

  1. These cookies sound divine!! I love love love brown butter and the thought of that plus chocolate chip cookies plus sea salt…. I see these in my future!

  2. OMG they sound divine..think I will be baking these this week:0) x

  3. Can’t wait to bake these! they look awesome Claire!

  4. These look so good! Im going to try them soon! =)

  5. Oh my word. I made these tonight – thank you so much for posting the recipe – they are to die for! I did sprinkle the sea salt before cooking because I wanted it to stick. What a difference the browned butter makes. I will try that with a few of my favorite cookie recipes.
    These were a huge it!! Great post

  6. Just made these tonight. They are fantastic, and I can tell already, will be a crowd pleaser.

  7. Pingback: Pumpkin Coffee Cake « thebitesizedbaker

  8. These sound and look INSANELY delicious!!! Can’t wait to try them!

  9. I just made these and it’s true…they are delicious! However, if I were to make them again, this is what I would change; I would use only semi sweet chocolate morsels, and the mini size, and about 3/4 c. less. I would also probably leave out the Nutella….I know, I know! But, it was tedious adding it to the cookies and to be honest I didn’t feel it made them great, so… I think what really makes this recipe special is the brown butter.

  10. I have two batches of these waiting in the fridge to bake. The dough is devine! I hope the cookie is just as delicious. Thinking of not adding the nutella to the second back as well.

  11. About how many does this recipe make?

  12. I have been making CC cookies with my son (9) for years now so we just used your recipe and we were both blown away !!! We always make from scratch and love trying new but now we don’t have to try new ones ! Bravo !!!! Thank u for sharing :)

  13. Hi! I want to make these today but one little question…how many oz of Nutella?? I bought a GINORMOUS jar from a box store so pretty sure its not that size jar…or maybe it is;) TU!

  14. My dough seems very dry. The chocolate chips barely stick to it and it crumbles when trying to wrap the Nutella. Is this how it is supposed to be? I haven’t seen my finished product yet but I do know that I followed the recipe completely!

    • Hi Jessica, is there a chance you forgot to add a wet ingredient or maybe miscalculated the flour amount? The dough is not too wet, but it has never broke apart for me. What was the end result for you??

  15. I want to make these amazingly delicious looking cookies for my annual cookie swap party this year! Does anyone know about how many the recipe makes? Thanks!!!!

  16. I’ve got the dough chilling in the fridge. My dough is not dry – it’s actually very “slick” looking – but I also had the problem of the chocolate chips not sticking to the dough. Also, I only added 1 cup of chips – I can’t imagine adding any more than that or the dough will be all chips!! I definitely didn’t miss an ingredient! Hopefully they will turn out as great as they look on this site!

  17. What should I do if I don’t have a stand mixer?

  18. OKAY … these are DELICIOUS! YUM YUM YUM

  19. These are my new go-to cookie! I’m making my third batch for a Christmas party tonight. I like the revisions you made, but I’m still adding the dark chocolate chips as I like to call them “triple chocolate chip” cookies-it adds another layer of decadence:) The sea salt is my favorite touch, too. Thank you for passing this amazing recipe along!

  20. Found these on pinterest, and made them for my mom’s birthday! I had to use a store bought mix; we didn’t have any of the other ingredients, but I browned the butter and used the nutella. They were delicious! I made them at a friend’s house, and they almost didn’t make it home. Irresistible and so simple! Thank you!

  21. Found these on pinterest, and made them for my mom’s birthday! I had to use a store bought mix; we didn’t have any of the other ingredients, but I browned the butter and used the nutella. They were delicious! I made them at a friend’s house, and they almost didn’t make it home. Irresistible and so simple! Thank you!

  22. These are AH-MAY-ZING! Made them as my secret santa gift for work…they are all gone. I love flaky sea salt as well as nutella. I made these just like the recipe & I couldn’t be happier! Now, I am trying to figure out a way to add browned butter to some other faves! Thank you & Happy Holidays!!

  23. The second I read the title of this pin on pinterest I knew I’d be making these ASAP!! I would already have a batch going but I have to run out and get chocolate chips first! These look beyond amazing!

  24. Mine spread out all over the pan, not sure if the amount of butter is correct?

  25. How long/well do these cookies store? Are they chewy on the day after they’re made? I want to make these on Thursday night and be ready to give them out on Friday :)

  26. These are fantastic! Thanks for sharing.

  27. I’m about to try these and am beyond excited, however I’m at an extremely high altitude (abt 7,000 ft) any tips or recommendations?

  28. These have been on my pinterest for a while now.. Today’s the day. We have a playdate today and I think these will be for the moms:) thank you for sharing!!!

  29. how cool should the butter get?

    • Just cool to the touch! I typically brown the butter first thing and then I go ahead with the recipe and incorporate it as soon as it is called for. You just don’t want to cook the eggs with hot butter!

  30. Can’t wait to try these. My 6yr old son is a Nutella monster. (He will not eat PB&J sandwiches, just Nutella &raspberry jelly sammies!) I think he will pass out from excitement with these. Hmmm…speaking of peanut butter…I wonder how they would turn out if you used pb instead of nutella?? Just may have to try that too!! Thanks!

  31. Made these and they were excellent! The only thing that i had to adjust was the time! I had to leave them in way longer than the times listed but the wait was worth it!!

  32. Made these tonight. I seriously couldn’t wait another day, I had to stay up until way past my bedtime to finish them. I’ll regret it at work tomorrow, but my co-workers won’t! These are ah-mazing!!!!!

  33. I know this was posted a long time ago, but just in case you see this…i don’t generally have greek yogurt or anything like it around, because i’m lactose intolerant. is there anything more commonplace i could use, or could i omit it?

    • Shaina, you can have greek yogurt if you are lactose intolerant! Yogurt has very little lactose, because the beneficial bacteria consume the lactose in the fermentation process. My daughter is lactose intolerant and can eat yogurt with no issues.

  34. I made these cookies around the holidays and they were a HUGE hit! My husband asks for these every week (no exaggeration), and he even says they are his all time favorite cookie (his mother is a phenomenal baker so that is a high honor!). Great recipe!GREAT cookie!

  35. This looks amazing and I just lost my cool by looking at your pics…. Uaaaah… I want one of these right now. Please!!!

  36. I just found this recipe via pinterest, and holy cow. My dough is chilling in the fridge as we speak, and I will probably make another batch. Just the taste of the dough with the brown butter is amazing! I went to Ambitious where you got the article, and her recipe calls for 3/4 semisweet, 1/2 cup milk, AND 1/2 dark/bittersweet. I actually bought all three kinds since I plan to make two batches, and figure I’ll use them anyway. I’m a chocolate fiend tho, so think only one cup of chips is NOT enough. Most recipes call for a whole regular sized bag of chips, which is more than a cup. Also, I like your way of stuffing the cookies better..seems easier than the way she did it.

  37. These sound amazing! About how many cookies do you get out of 1 recipe? And do you think the would freeze well?

  38. These are the best! I made them for a block party and everyone was telling me how amazing they were. My husband said they are the best cookies I’ve made!

  39. This maybe sounds a bit daft , but how do you brown butter? I do a lot of baking but have never heard of ‘ browning butter ‘ before

  40. I’ve baked these cookies four times since finding the recipe. They’re that good. My husband and I thank you!!

  41. I made there today for my bunco group… was disappointed I followed the directions exactly but the dough seemed really dry and only came up with 14 large cookies… that spread out really thin rather than looking like the ones in the picture that look a bit thicker…. did I do something wrong?

  42. Can’t wait to try these. Is there some way to change the printing format for your recipes. I was shocked to turn around and see that 14 pages had printed to get this recipe. What a waste of paper and ink.

  43. Hi- i dont have any greek yogurt- would it turn out bad if i don’t put it in? :(

  44. These look amazing! i must make them! (yes, took me a while to discover the recipe)

    But since i’m new to this whole browned butter thing, i have a question:
    Does it really work when the butter is completely melted like that? for most cookie recipes you only need to soften the butter. plus, how do you whisk the butter and sugar to be fluffy if the butter is melted?

    Thanks!

  45. Do you know if they freeze well? I want to make some ahead of time for Christmas!

  46. They are in a word….EPIC!

  47. Pingback: Nutella-Stuffed Browned-Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt | Daisy Bites

  48. do you let the butter reharden or use it in liquid form?

  49. I am so confused… not sure if it someone else has asked this question….
    I have read and reread the recipe and it does not say to brown the butter….
    I am not an expert in anything in the kitchen so please help!!!!
    If the butter is to be browned HOW??

    Confused in Florida

  50. Recommend browning the butter – and refrigerating to allow it to get solid. Then prepare as you would normal chocolate chip cookies. Much easier to work with dough when butter is creamed with the sugar…

    Also – Spread nutella in greased sheet pan and freeze. Cut small squares – roll into balls and insert into dough… You will be SO HAPPY you did this instead of messing with soft nutella….

  51. Do you think you could use caramel instead of the nutella?

  52. Do you think this would work with caramel instead of nutella?

    • Try Rollos! I bet that would work beautifully. (I made some with peanut butter and that is also ridiculously delicious.) :)

  53. Has anyone tried making them in a muffin tin?

  54. I have to try these but I think I will substitute Chocolate Philadelphia Cream Cheese for the Nutella.

  55. hello, i do not own a stand mixer……i assume i can do this by hand it will just be more difficult to mix? please advise…..thanks!

  56. Quick question-Will these ship? I ask because we are starting our annual Cookie Mailing, and I know a few people who would chew through the box to get to these cookies.

  57. Can I leave out the yogurt!? i dont have any.

  58. I’m sure they are delicious, but they are not nut allergy friendly. These kind of cookies cause many allergic reactions because they have hidden or unexpected ingredients that many people wouldn’t think are in a chocolate chip cookie.

  59. Do you add a full jar of Nutella or just a few tablespoons for a batch of 24 cookies?

    • Never mind…It would be helpful if I had read all the directions!!! I made them and they are AWESOME!

  60. Pingback: Sunday always comes too late for link love | Grumpy rumblings of the (formerly!) untenured

  61. Is it possible to replace the Greek yogurt with sour cream?

  62. Just made these and they are hands down the best tasting cookie I’ve ever made! I left the dough in the fridge for about 2.5 hours and it was pretty hard when I tried to roll into balls and the chocolate chips kept popping out. I just pushed the chocolate chips back into the dough and made it work. It made 25 pretty large cookies. Yummy!!!

  63. I’ve had bad luck when doubling recipes in the past, but I feel I need at least 48 of these between my family and the cookie swap I’m planning to bring them to… Has anyone made a double batch yet? Was it successful?

  64. Pingback: Christmas Cookies

  65. Amazing looking…. must get ingredients.

  66. Thank you! i have never baked before, and i was really nervous because i dont have the mixing machine, these cookies came out perfect!!! Thank you so much for sharing!

  67. My mom is forcing me to make these -_- lol I’m too excited because I’m allergic to Nutella so I won’t be able to try them :(

  68. Pingback: Rollo Stuffed Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies | Jeanie and Lulu's Kitchen

  69. I just made these tonight and they were INCREDIBLE! I gave you a huge shout out on my blog about it :-). Instead of nutella, I had rollos and I stuffed the cookies with them. The caramel with the sea salt…OMG!!!

  70. This is amazing. Your enthusiasm for these cookies is amazing. My family…

    shall be amazed.

  71. Any way to make these paleo-ish???

  72. Am I stupid in asking what you mean by browned butter? (I’m from Scotland)

  73. Ok, I feel like an idiot asking this, but how do I ‘brown butter’? P.s., if you are a salty sweet fan, have you ever tried dark chocolate bars with sea salt? DiBruno Brothers (Philadelphia) makes them.

  74. I am rummaging for the ingredients right now. As it is snowing heavily I might as well enjoy the snow whilst enjoying these yummy cookies.

  75. Love this! I’ve been sprinkling chocolate chip cookie with sea salt for a while now, but now to add Nutella! Yum!

  76. OMG… I’m so going to try these when I’ve converted measurements to UK as I find cups difficult to work with. These sound divine, please what is all-purpose flour?! Is that self-raising or plain??? Sorry I’m not sure of the equivalent. Thank you xXx

  77. I’m in the process of making these. I made the dough last night and put it in the fridge. When they cook, the spread out. I know I measured everything correctly. Thoughts? I’m so disappointed. I’m making them for a cookie swap tomorrow.

  78. Nutella cookies

  79. I make really good chocolate chip cookies. Your ingredients are very similar to mine although I used 2 eggs and no yogurt. Does the egg yoke in lieu of an entire 2nd egg and the yogurt make a difference? I’ve been using the old Nestle tollhouse recipe with a few tweeks such as extra vanilla and lots of extra chips. I melt the butter in the microwave, but how does one brown butter. You mentioned you had link to that process, but can’t find it.

    BTW I do all my mixing of ingredients by hand. No big mixer in my kitchen. No room!

  80. And where is the Nutrition info? I wonder if the cocaine addicted rats would prefer these over oreos???

    • Hi Sue, I don’t include the nutritional information because the size of the cookie and ingredients varies for every baker. I would imagine the rats wouldn’t have a preference between the two cookies since they’re both high-calorie/high-sugar foods, BUT at least they’re not doing drugs anymore!

  81. OMG!!! These are incredible. I’m not a baker – I can cook a mean dinner, but desserts always scare me. I made these for Christmas dinner only because my husband asked. They are involved, but nothing like what I was expecting. I really didn’t have to do much more than I would for box cookies. One suggestion though, keep everything as cold as you can. My dough started getting really sticky so I cut a chunk off to work with & threw the rest back in the fridge. Same for the Nutella. Dipped up some to work with, kept the jar in the fridge. It helped a lot!

  82. I made these cookies last week and they are delicious. Making some more tonight. They are a pain in the butt to put together with the Nutella but soooo worth it once they are done. I would not leave this step out.

  83. The cookies were delicious… But mine turned out Huge and the color of chocolate cookies. Did I brown butter too long? The photo above the cookies look smaller and like normal color chocolate chip cookies. Any tips?
    Thank you!

    • Hi Shelley, did you use chilled Nutella when you stuffed the cookies? Sometimes, when the Nutella starts to warm up, it starts melding with the dough. I would suggest rolling out only 1 tablespoon of cookie dough if you want smaller cookies and adjust the Nutella accordingly. Let me know if that works!

  84. For the love of god. Why did I make these? I have never “lost control” of myself around food like I did when I first tasted the cookie dough. I was like a cat with cat nip, and had to be pulled away. Best cookie ever hands down.

  85. I just finished making these…Holy. Crap! So delicious! My last few I tried with peanut butter AND Nutella, because why not? Great recipe. I am making another batch as I was asked, “Are there anymore?” THANK YOU!

  86. When you brown the butter, do you then include both the milk solids (floating on top) and the clear browned butter in the recipe? Thanks! Can’t wait to try these!!!

  87. These are amazing! My husband, who does not like chocolate, and chocolate chip cookies are his least favorite, was WAITING BY THE OVEN WITH A PLATE! I made 2 batches last week, and was strongly requested to make another batch today! They really are wonderful. Thanks!

  88. This recipe sounds amazing!!!!!! Im going to make them with Gluten Free all-purpose flour…my mouth is watering already….Thanks

  89. Just took a savory bite and now I’m HOOKED!!! Thanks so much for the recipe! Please come out with more cookie recipes! I’ve got to feed the cookie monsters of the world!!

  90. Pingback: Baking Disasters! | Triathlete Treats

  91. What happens if i don’t refrigerate the dough for 2 hours? Will it still be okay?

  92. Why the yogurt? Can I leave it out?

  93. I made the dough last night and left it in the fridge overnight. Now it’s really hard. Hoping i didn’t do something wrong!

  94. Ok, I hardly ever comment when I try a recipe but I HAD TO this time. These cookies are life-changing. I made a batch on Saturday, and then had to make a double batch on Sunday! The only thing is that the cookies came out a lil more greasy than I’d like. Would reducing the butter slightly help? Or do you reckon it might be because of the Nutella?

    • Hi Shakira, I love your enthusiasm! It most likely has to do with the butter, it is possible you’re using a butter with a higher fat content? Also, make sure the butter is cooled completely before mixing it with the sugars and let the dough rest in the fridge for AT LEAST two hours so the dough can soak up all of the butter. Let me know if that works!

  95. Pingback: Nutella and Dulce de Leche Stuffed Double Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt | thebitesizedbaker

  96. Pingback: Necessities for a Cozier Lifestyle | Cozy's Concept

  97. Geoff: I present the first batch of Nutella-stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies!

    Brigid: t’s like they’re trying to camouflage themselves in your countertop, but something tells me they will not be saved!

    Geoff: Yeah, Brigid, I also have a chocolate chip countertop!

  98. I pinned this on pinterest a long time ago and revisited it today, so good!!

  99. Pingback: Blueberry Muffins | thebitesizedbaker

  100. Pingback: Blueberry Muffins | thebitesizedbaker

  101. I have made these cookies a few times and they’ve turned out super, unbelievably, melt-in-your-mouth delicious every time. The great thing is you don’t have to be a gourmet baker to make them. They’re easy and relatively quick. The browned butter adds such a unique flavor that average chocolate chip cookies don’t have, and who doesn’t love Nutella? The sea salt is just the cherry on top. The only advice I would give is that I’ve had better luck using un-chilled Nutella. Thanks for a great recipe!

  102. Pingback: The Best Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies | thebitesizedbaker

  103. Pingback: Nutella-Stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt | Andymatic

  104. I am in the process of making these cookies right now for my husbands birthday! He loves cookies (what man doesn’t) and loves nutella! I thought these would be perfect! The dough kinda reminds me of caramel (my favorite sweet!) so I am sooo incredibly excited! Two hours wont go fast enough! I did some things different though…Instead of actual eggs I used Energy Egg Replacement (didn’t have eggs). Also I browned the butter and put it right into the sugar to mix (maybe that’s why its so caramelly?) So we shall see what two hours does to the dough! Cant wait to eat these!!

    • they are finished…. Have you ever watched the movie “Ever After” with Drew Berrymore? You know the part when the step sister are in the market with the prince and the blonde tastes chocolate for the first time. She said it was sinful…..These have the same reaction! Sinful! So good! I think I might have to put browned butter into everything now!!

  105. Delicious! My nephews and niece loved them, and so did all the adults. I put the Nutella deep in the corner of a zipper bag and snip the tip – much easier to pipe it onto the cookie than try to spoon it on. Neater too.

  106. I made these after seeing these on your site and the original site- Ambitious Kitchen! They were wonderful! I made a few minor changes and posted them on my blog! Thanks for sharing!(:

  107. Reblogged this on Foodie Yogie's Blog and commented:
    Making these tonight!

  108. Pingback: Nutella-Stuffed Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt | finding baker's bliss

  109. just started baking and made these as my 2nd project :) came out perf! they are super good :) thanks for this!

  110. They taste delicious,the recipe is a keeper,thanks for sharing the recipe

  111. Pingback: Two Treats to Go Nuts Over | Little Miss Sweet Tooth

  112. Pingback: End-of-Semester Stress Disorder | Sara has Something to Say.

  113. Pingback: The Best Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies | The Bite-Sized Baker

  114. Pingback: Pumpkin Coffee Cake | The Bite-Sized Baker

  115. Pingback: Blueberry Muffins | The Bite-Sized Baker

  116. Pingback: Nutella and Dulce de Leche Stuffed Double Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt | The Bite-Sized Baker

  117. Pingback: Nutella Chocolate Cookies | The Stoner Girls' Guide

  118. Pingback: Nutella Chocolate Cookies | The Stoner Girls' Guide

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *